7 Big Mistakes to Avoid When Selling Crochet Items
Do you ever sit there, yarn in hand, wondering if selling crochet items is even worth it?
You scroll past picture-perfect Instagram feeds, and Etsy stores with thousands of reviews… and suddenly your little corner of the internet feels kinda small.
You think, How do they do it? What am I missing? And worse—What if I mess this up before I even get going?
Starting something new—especially something this close to your heart—is vulnerable.
You’re putting your creativity out there and hoping someone sees it.
Buys it. Values it.
Most of what’s tripping people up isn’t a lack of talent. It’s a few common missteps that no one really talks about.
In this post, we’ll walk through the biggest mistakes new crochet sellers make—and exactly how to sidestep them. Because your creativity deserves a fighting chance. And yes, you can turn your yarn stash into something that sells.
Why I Had to Write This
(And Why You’ll Be Glad You Read It)
I didn’t plan to write this post. Not at first.
But over the last few months, I kept hearing the same things from crocheters trying to turn their passion into income.
Things like:
“I don’t get it—I’ve made some sales, but it’s all so slow.”
“I feel like I’m doing all the things, but nothing’s really working.”
“Everyone says it’s possible to make money from crochet, but no one tells you how to actually make it work.”
And I recognised the frustration. Because I’ve been there too—untangling the mess of marketing advice, pricing doubts, and wondering why the beautiful thing you made with so much love is still sitting unsold.
What’s really holding people back when they’re selling crochet items?
It’s usually not lack of skill or creativity.
It’s just a few common mistakes—blind spots—that quietly block sales, drain energy, and keep talented makers stuck in a cycle that feels more like guesswork than growth.
So I wrote this for you.
To save you time. To spare you some of the stress. And to help you build a business that doesn’t just bring in a few pounds here and there—but one that’s steady, sustainable, and joyful to run.
In the next sections, you’ll learn:
What’s really stopping your products from selling—and how to fix it
Why some shops take off while others stay quiet
The small mindset shifts and strategies that make a big difference when it comes to making money from crochet
Let’s dive in and start untangling it—one mistake at a time.
Mistake #1: The Maker Mindset That Sabotages Selling Crochet Items
There’s something magical about making.
Yarn in hand, hooks moving rhythmically, a beautiful design taking shape right before your eyes. It’s satisfying.
It’s calming. And it’s probably the reason you started crocheting in the first place.
But here’s the truth most sellers don’t want to admit: making things isn’t the same as making a business.
Too often, crocheters who start selling crochet items fall into a cycle of “make, post, hope.”
You make a hat. You post it on Instagram. You wait.
Maybe it sells, maybe it doesn’t. So you make something else and try again.
That’s not a business. That’s a hamster wheel.
Running a real crochet business means stepping outside the maker mindset.
It means planning for profit, not just passion.
It means asking hard questions like:
How long does it take me to make this?
What’s my hourly rate?
How much do I need to earn each month?
If you’re charging £25 for a blanket that took you 12 hours to make, that’s not pricing—it’s wishful thinking.
And if you’re undercharging just because “it’s fun” or “people won’t pay more,” you’re not just hurting yourself—you’re undervaluing the entire craft.
Want a simple way to shift into business mode? Create product tiers.
Start with:
A low-ticket offer (like a quick downloadable pattern)
A mid-tier product (maybe a made-to-order wearable)
A premium option (like a custom baby set or full kit)
This gives you flexibility, multiple income streams, and—most importantly—a clear path to scale.
You don’t need to abandon the joy of making. But you do need a plan that makes the joy sustainable.
How To Start A Crochet Business That Earns $1,000+ Monthly - start earning money from your crochet business
Mistake #2: How a Vague Niche Kills Your Chances of Selling Crochet Items
If your business pitch sounds something like, “I sell crochet,” we need to talk.
Because saying “I sell crochet” is like saying “I sell food.”
It doesn’t tell people what you really do, who you serve, or why they should buy from you instead of the 10,000 other crochet shops out there.
This is one of the biggest pitfalls in selling crochet items—being too broad. And while it feels safer to appeal to everyone, it actually makes it way harder to connect with anyone.
Think about it: if someone is scrolling Etsy looking for a gift for their outdoorsy sister who loves camping, and they come across your shop that says “Handmade Crochet Items,” are they going to click?
Probably not.
But if your brand says “Cosy Crochet Gear for Outdoor Lovers,” now you’ve got their attention.
That’s the power of a niche. It speaks directly to someone instead of vaguely to everyone.
Your niche doesn’t have to be tiny, but it does have to be clear. And it needs to guide everything—from what you make to how you photograph, describe, and market it.
Here are a few niche ideas that stand out:
Geeky fandom baby sets
Plant-themed home décor for urban jungles
Mood-boosting crochet for mental health
Crochet patterns for left-handed beginners
See the difference?
You’re not just selling crochet items.
You’re solving a specific problem, sparking joy for a specific person, or fitting into a specific lifestyle.
If you're unsure where to start, build a quick customer avatar.
Ask:
Who’s buying from me?
What do they care about?
What kind of lifestyle do they live?
How can my crochet fit into that?
And test your ideas. Pinterest trends, Etsy search results, and even Instagram comments can offer clues.
Remember, people don’t just buy things—they buy identity. Help them see themselves in your product, and they’ll hit “add to cart” without hesitation.
How to Create Scroll‑Stopping Crochet Product Photos That Sell - Clear branding and a defined niche makes it easier for the right customers to say yes.
Mistake #3: Why One-Off Products Make Selling Crochet Items Exhausting
Custom orders feel flattering at first.
Someone wants you to make them something special. It’s exciting. It’s validating.
But it can also be a trap.
When you rely on one-off pieces, you're stuck in a cycle that’s hard to break. You finish one item, start another.
You have to photograph it, list it, promote it… over and over again. There's no rhythm, no repeat customers, no breathing room.
Selling crochet items this way means you’re always working to sell instead of selling what works.
And let’s not even talk about the emotional labour that comes with custom orders.
The back-and-forth messages.
The changes.
The pressure to please.
All for a price that probably doesn’t cover the stress.
Want freedom? Want growth? Then you need to standardize your offer.
That means:
Creating signature product lines with repeatable designs
Offering pattern bundles instead of one pattern at a time
Packaging digital templates or kits that you can sell again and again
This is the difference between a job and a business. When your business depends on your hands constantly moving, you’re the bottleneck. When you create systems and scalable offers, the sky’s the limit.
Let’s say you make a bestselling beanie. Instead of offering 12 colours and custom sizing, lock in 3 standard colours, 2 sizes, and batch your production. Suddenly you’ve saved time, simplified your life, and still have a high-quality product that meets your customer’s needs.
Here’s something counterintuitive: less variety often equals more sales. Too much choice overwhelms buyers.
Streamlined collections make your shop look confident, cohesive, and easy to shop.
So instead of treating every order like a new challenge, build products that become your business foundation. That way, you’re not just crocheting for today—you’re building something that lasts.
Mistake #4: Skipping Digital Products When Selling Crochet Items
Selling crochet items is rewarding—but it’s also exhausting if every sale relies on your hands constantly making something new.
What if you could sell something once and keep earning from it forever?
That’s the power of digital products. And yet, so many crochet sellers brush them off.
They say things like, “I’m not techy,” or “I don’t think anyone would pay for a PDF.”
But they do. All the time.
Patterns
Guides
Templates
Workshop recordings
—people are searching for these every single day.
And not just beginners. Even experienced crocheters are looking for shortcuts, inspiration, and fresh ideas.
The beauty of digital products is that they scale without taking more of your time. Make it once. Sell it a hundred times.
No packaging. No postage. No yarn shortages. Just passive income that works in the background while you focus on the creative side.
You don’t have to reinvent the wheel, either.
Think small to start:
Turn a popular design into a pattern with clear instructions and tips
Create a mini-guide to customizing sizing or adapting colors
Bundle a few coordinating patterns as a themed set
You could even record a short video walking through a project and sell it as a workshop-style tutorial.
Many buyers will pay extra just to see how it’s done, not just read it.
And here’s what’s really surprising: sometimes, your digital products will sell better than your finished items.
Because they’re more affordable, they appeal to a wider audience, and they let your customers feel empowered and creative too.
If you’ve been heads-down stitching and haven’t created any kind of digital offer, now’s the time. You’re sitting on a goldmine of knowledge and skill. Package it. Share it. Sell it.
11 Digital Products That Go Beyond Patterns - 11 smart digital product ideas for crocheters.
Mistake #5: Selling Crochet Items Without a Story Is Costing You Sales
You can have the prettiest stitches in the world, but if your marketing says, “Handmade hat—£20,” you’re not giving anyone a reason to care.
In today’s world, we don’t just buy products—we buy stories. Emotion. Connection. Identity.
This is where many people get stuck when selling crochet items. They think showing a photo is enough. But people need more.
They want to know why you made it.
Who it’s for.
What problem it solves.
What feeling it creates.
Is it a hat for moms who never have time for themselves? A wall hanging that brings calm to chaotic homes? A rainbow plushie that helps anxious kids feel safe?
That’s what people connect with. That’s what they remember.
When you tell a story, you create meaning. And meaning sells.
It’s not just about the product. It’s about the transformation. What’s life like before your product? What’s it like after?
Let’s say you offer a crochet kit. Instead of saying “Comes with hook and yarn,” say:
“Everything you need to spend a quiet, cozy afternoon making something with your hands—and finally taking a break from the chaos.”
See the difference? One is a list. The other is a feeling.
Strategy matters too. If you’re randomly posting on Instagram and hoping for a sale, you’re gambling, not growing. You need a clear plan:
Where do your ideal customers hang out?
What kind of content grabs their attention?
How do you move them from curious to committed?
Hint: A lead magnet (like a free pattern or printable) paired with email marketing is wildly effective—and most crochet sellers still aren’t doing it.
If your posts aren’t converting, it’s not that your work isn’t good enough. You just haven’t told the right story yet.
You can read more about email marketing here: How To Start A Newsletter
Want to offer more than a cookie-cutter pattern?
The Crochet Customisation Kit helps you add personality and polish to every piece you sell—so your products look and feel like you.
✨ Includes a technical conversation chart and cheat-sheets so that you can customise any crochet pattern with ease.
Get the Kit → Download Now!
Mistake #6: How Staying Invisible Hurts When You're Selling Crochet Item
This one’s tough. Putting yourself out there is scary. But staying invisible is worse.
Many crochet sellers stick to the same comfort-zone tactics—posting to Instagram now and then, maybe sharing in a Facebook group, hoping someone stumbles across their listing.
And when it doesn’t work?
They either give up or keep doing the same thing, louder.
Selling crochet items means being visible.
Consistently. Confidently. Creatively.
And visibility isn’t just about more posts—it’s about better strategy.
Are you using Pinterest to drive traffic to your patterns?
Are you building an email list so you can talk directly to people who actually want what you’re selling?
Are you showing behind the scenes, teaching tips, or sharing the “why” behind your brand?
Here’s what most crochet sellers don’t realize: your audience needs to hear about your offer multiple times before they act. Not once. Not twice. At least seven times. That’s not pushy—that’s marketing psychology.
And if you’re always saying the same thing—“Here’s my new listing,” “Available now,” “DM to order”—people tune out.
They need variety. Value. A reason to care.
Try rotating between:
Education (e.g. “Why I use this yarn and how it affects durability”)
Storytelling (e.g. “This blanket was inspired by my grandma’s garden”)
Connection (e.g. “Here’s what I made when I felt burned out—what’s your go-to project?”)
Offers (e.g. “This kit’s only available through Sunday!”)
Visibility isn’t vanity. It’s vital. The more people see you, the more they trust you. And the more they trust you, the more they buy.
Set Up Email Automation for Your Craft Newsletter - your marketing needs momentum, not just repetition.
Mistake #7: Selling Crochet Items Only on Etsy? Here’s Why That’s Risky
Etsy is great—until it’s not.
One algorithm change, one random policy update, one sudden influx of copycat shops... and boom.
Your income’s down 50% overnight. And you’ve got no backup.
That’s the danger of building your business on someone else’s land.
Many crochet sellers get comfortable on Etsy, or maybe on Instagram, and never expand beyond it.
It’s understandable.
It’s easy.
But it’s risky.
If you're serious about selling crochet items long-term, you need multiple streams of traffic and income—and the most important one is your email list.
An email list is something you own. No algorithm. No competition. Just a direct line to people who already like your work.
It’s powerful. And it’s underused.
Your website is another key asset. Even a simple one-pager with a lead magnet and product links is better than none.
Why? Because it positions you as a brand, not just another seller.
The real magic happens when you combine the two:
Website → Offers a freebie (like “10 Must-Have Crochet Tools”)
Freebie → Builds your list
Email list → Sells your products consistently and on your terms
That’s a foundation. That’s freedom. That’s how you stop depending on platforms that don’t care whether you succeed or not.
So if you've been putting off building your own space online, let this be your sign.
It doesn’t have to be fancy.
But it does have to be yours.
You’re Not Just Selling Crochet Items — You’re Building a Legacy
Every product you sell brings your creativity to life.
And every mistake? It’s not failure. It’s feedback. It’s growth. It’s a stepping stone on the path to something bigger.
You don’t need to hustle harder, be on every platform, or become someone you’re not.
You just need clarity, confidence, and a bit of strategy behind your passion. The fact that you’re here, learning how to avoid these mistakes, means you already care deeply about doing this right.
So take what you’ve learned.
Make the tweaks.
Reclaim your time.
Raise your prices.
Show up for your business the same way you show up for your craft—with heart, intention, and a whole lot of grit.
Because selling crochet items isn’t just about making money.
It’s about making meaning.
And you are more than capable of doing both.
What Next?
Loved this post? Let’s keep the momentum going.
🧶 Leave a comment below—what digital product idea are you most excited to try? Or have you already created something amazing? I’d love to hear about it.
📌 Save this post to Pinterest so you can come back to it whenever you need a burst of inspiration. It’s one of those ones you’ll want to revisit.
📥 Grab your free copy of The Crocheter’s Profit Blueprint—it’s packed with simple, smart steps to start making money with crochet (without the burnout).
✨ Want more support? Head to the Monetize Your Crochet page to dive deeper. You’ll find tools, ideas, and offers designed to help you turn your yarn into income—your way.
Let’s build something beautiful together—one stitch, one sale, one smart step at a time.
More inspiring posts
Thinking about selling crochet items but not sure why your shop isn’t growing—or where to even begin? This post breaks down the most common mistakes new crochet sellers make and how to avoid them, so you can turn your handmade passion into profit (without burning out or second-guessing every step).